Preliminary Finals

Sydney 2nd • 18-5
vs
Fremantle 1st • 19-4

SCG  ·  Fri 18 Sep, 7:40 PM AEST

Recommendation

Fremantle  63%

Medium

Margin: ~12 pts (1–47)

37%
63%
AI edge AI agrees Multi Factor

Leans Fremantle  ·  Medium

Sydney missing four A-graders tilts prelim calculus toward Freo

Mills, Warner, Heeney, and Cunningham out guts Sydney's spine. Market line of 7.5 underestimates that talent drain; model's 12-pt margin and Freo's minor-premier status align with backing the visitors despite umpire lean

Twelve likely outs leave Sydney thin for Freo's rare prelim shot

Fremantle gets the nod here largely on consensus power ratings and a significant availability edge, and that combination is hard to argue against in a preliminary final. The Dockers carry just 2 likely outs against Sydney's staggering 12, with Callum Mills now joining Harry Cunningham on the casualty list. Losing a quarter of your best 22 in September is brutal, and while Sydney's season-long scoring numbers are impressive (+30 avg margin), depth gets tested differently when the stakes are existential. The counterpoint is real: Fremantle have travelled interstate, and Sydney's 18-5 record at home this year shows they're no pushovers at the SCG under lights. Still, the Dockers finished atop the ladder for a reason, their squad is close to full strength with potential reinforcements from Sweid and Riddle among others, and the model sees that personnel gulf as the decisive factor even accounting for the travel impost.

Match summary

Form · Injury · Travel

Form SYD · big edge
SYD Recent margin form is running 67.5 pts better. FRE
Injury FRE · big edge
SYD Outs currently sit 12-2 across the two squads. FRE
Travel SYD · big edge
SYD interstate travel · rest differential FRE
Umpire edge SYD · solid edge
SYD Crew club residual signal 5.0 pts over 272 samples; context only. FRE
Rub of the green SYD · solid edge
SYD Sydney +3.2 pts · SYD +0.6 · FRE -2.7 FRE
Venue SYD · solid edge
SYD true home ground FRE

Last time they played

R18 2026 · Optus Stadium

Fremantle 111 def Sydney 73 Fremantle by 38 Normal
Relevance 54% (Medium) Overlap 78% Trust: High

Use last result: With caution

Since they last met

Team selection diff

Sydney 7 in · 7 out
Sydney moderately weaker
IN
Justin McInerney Jesse Dattoli Braeden Campbell Sam Wicks +3 more
OUT
Heeney, Isaac Warner, Chad Blakey, Nick Mills, Callum +4 more
Fremantle 3 in · 3 out
Fremantle slightly stronger
IN
Hayden Young Corey Wagner Oscar McDonald
OUT
ODriscoll, Nathan OMeara, Jaeger Cox, Brennan Brandon Walker +4 more
Change summary
Selection Fremantle improved
Umpires Now favour Sydney
Venue Optus → SCG (still favours Sydney; less comparable)
Availability Favours Fremantle
Takeaway

Treat the old result cautiously because availability now favours Fremantle.

Then vs Now

Current tipping inputs against the previous meeting
Metric Trend
Power Sydney improved
Form Similar
Availability Fremantle improved
Market Sydney improved

Umpire crew

Crew read

Compact historical lean by side

Rub of the green SYD +0.6 · FRE -2.7

Crew lean: Sydney +3.2 pts

Sydney Fremantle

272 combined team-specific lined samples

Weather ✓ Fine · 23.0°C · forecast Fri 18 Sep
Odds Sydney: $2.25  ·  Fremantle: $1.60
Market line 7.5
Recent H2H
Sydney lead the last 5 meetings 3-2 (SCG: 1-1)
FRE +38
R18 2026 Optus
SYD +11
R17 2025 SCG
SYD +3
R2 2025 Optus
FRE +1
R16 2024 SCG
SYD +48
R9 2024 Optus

Biggest scalp

Opponent quality first; margin breaks ties.

Sydney
Upset
def. Brisbane Lions
Margin +53
Opp 3rd
Round F1
Venue SCG
Fremantle
Rated win
def. Sydney
Margin +38
Opp 2nd
Round R18
Venue Optus Stadium

Injury / Availability

Sydney more affected by availability this week

Sydney 12 out · 1 test
Major
Impact 11.9 pts Rating +4.4→+2.1
Unavailable Isaac Heeney
Unavailable Chad Warner
Unavailable Nick Blakey
Test Noah Chamberlain
Fremantle 2 out · 4 tests
Minor
Impact Pending Rating +0.3→+0.2
Unavailable Ollie Murphy
Unavailable Sam Sturt
Test Brandon Walker Test Adam Sweid Test Aiden Riddle
Injury list
Sydney
Unavailable
Isaac Heeney season · Key out · 2.24 pts risk
Unavailable
Chad Warner season · Key out · 1.65 pts risk
Unavailable
Nick Blakey season · Key out · 1.32 pts risk
Unavailable
Callum Mills season · Key out · 1.12 pts risk
Unavailable
Riley Bice season · Key out · 0.76 pts risk
Unavailable
James Jordon season
Unavailable
Liam Hetherton season
Unavailable
Max King season
Unavailable
Peter Ladhams season
Unavailable
Will Edwards season
Out
Harry Cunningham injured
Out
Ned Bowman 1 week
Test
Noah Chamberlain Test / uncertain
Fremantle
Unavailable
Ollie Murphy season
Unavailable
Sam Sturt indefinite
Test
Brandon Walker Test / uncertain · 0.01 pts risk
Test
Adam Sweid Test / uncertain
Test
Aiden Riddle Test / uncertain
Test
Sean Darcy Test / uncertain

Venue performance

SCG

Metric SYD FRE
Win rate 69% 35%
Avg margin +22 -16

Based on 199 completed games at SCG

Season performance

Metric SYD FRE
Record 19-5 20-5
Avg margin +30 +24
True Form score +16.6 +12.3
Form heat Red hot Cold
Model Power +4.4 +0.3
Schedule Difficulty Average draw Average draw
Upset win % 20% 50%
Win % vs top 8 50% 77%
Home win % vs interstate 92% 92%
Road win % vs interstate 60% 64%

Season trend

Ladder, true form, model power and injury by round

OR-R24

Ladder trend

After each completed round

1 10 18 Sydney · After OR beat Carlton 132-69 (+63) · Ladder 1st Sydney · After R1 beat Brisbane Lions 104-60 (+44) · Ladder 1st Sydney · After R2 lost to Hawthorn 82-99 (-17) · Ladder 3rd Sydney · After R4 beat West Coast 163-35 (+128) · Ladder 2nd Sydney · After R5 beat Gold Coast 100-68 (+32) · Ladder 1st Sydney · After R6 beat GWS 107-66 (+41) · Ladder 1st Sydney · After R7 beat Western Bulldogs 126-60 (+66) · Ladder 1st Sydney · After R8 beat Melbourne 131-114 (+17) · Ladder 1st Sydney · After R9 beat North Melbourne 105-97 (+8) · Ladder 1st Sydney · After R10 beat Collingwood 81-75 (+6) · Ladder 1st Sydney · After R11 lost to Geelong 80-107 (-27) · Ladder 2nd Sydney · After R12 beat Richmond 170-56 (+114) · Ladder 2nd Sydney · After R13 beat St Kilda 104-102 (+2) · Ladder 2nd Sydney · After R14 beat Port Adelaide 93-90 (+3) · Ladder 2nd Sydney · After R16 lost to Brisbane Lions 83-126 (-43) · Ladder 2nd Sydney · After R17 beat Western Bulldogs 90-55 (+35) · Ladder 2nd Sydney · After R18 lost to Fremantle 73-111 (-38) · Ladder 2nd Sydney · After R19 lost to Adelaide 71-87 (-16) · Ladder 2nd Sydney · After R20 beat GWS 139-88 (+51) · Ladder 2nd Sydney · After R21 beat St Kilda 107-88 (+19) · Ladder 2nd Sydney · After R22 beat Port Adelaide 167-70 (+97) · Ladder 2nd Sydney · After R23 beat Essendon 112-76 (+36) · Ladder 2nd Sydney · After R24 beat North Melbourne 123-70 (+53) · Ladder 2nd Fremantle · After R1 lost to Geelong 100-110 (-10) · Ladder 13th Fremantle · After R2 beat Melbourne 118-70 (+48) · Ladder 5th Fremantle · After R3 beat Richmond 103-43 (+60) · Ladder 3rd Fremantle · After R4 beat Adelaide 78-76 (+2) · Ladder 4th Fremantle · After R5 beat Collingwood 45-39 (+6) · Ladder 2nd Fremantle · After R6 beat West Coast 97-41 (+56) · Ladder 2nd Fremantle · After R7 beat Carlton 103-89 (+14) · Ladder 2nd Fremantle · After R8 beat Western Bulldogs 114-102 (+12) · Ladder 2nd Fremantle · After R9 beat Hawthorn 88-73 (+15) · Ladder 2nd Fremantle · After R10 beat Essendon 104-61 (+43) · Ladder 2nd Fremantle · After R11 beat St Kilda 104-74 (+30) · Ladder 1st Fremantle · After R12 beat Brisbane Lions 103-78 (+25) · Ladder 1st Fremantle · After R13 beat North Melbourne 155-31 (+124) · Ladder 1st Fremantle · After R15 beat Geelong 99-90 (+9) · Ladder 1st Fremantle · After R16 beat Gold Coast 80-29 (+51) · Ladder 1st Fremantle · After R17 lost to GWS 88-109 (-21) · Ladder 1st Fremantle · After R18 beat Sydney 111-73 (+38) · Ladder 1st Fremantle · After R19 beat Port Adelaide 103-75 (+28) · Ladder 1st Fremantle · After R20 beat West Coast 112-42 (+70) · Ladder 1st Fremantle · After R21 beat Western Bulldogs 78-41 (+37) · Ladder 1st Fremantle · After R22 lost to Melbourne 109-113 (-4) · Ladder 1st Fremantle · After R23 beat Adelaide 112-88 (+24) · Ladder 1st Fremantle · After R24 lost to Carlton 82-119 (-37) · Ladder 1st Fremantle 1st Sydney 2nd OR R6 R12 R18 R24

Season to date

W
vs Brisbane Lions +53 · F1 SCG
W
vs North Melbourne +53 · R24 SCG
W
vs Essendon +36 · R23 MCG
W
vs Port Adelaide +97 · R22 SCG
W
vs St Kilda +19 · R21 Marvel
19 older results
W
vs GWS +51 · R20 ENGIE
L
vs Adelaide -16 · R19 SCG
L
vs Fremantle -38 · R18 Optus
W
vs Western Bulldogs +35 · R17 SCG
L
vs Brisbane Lions -43 · R16 Gabba
W
vs Port Adelaide +3 · R14 Adel Oval
W
vs St Kilda +2 · R13 SCG
W
vs Richmond +114 · R12 SCG
L
vs Geelong -27 · R11 Kardinia
W
vs Collingwood +6 · R10 SCG
W
vs North Melbourne +8 · R9 Marvel
W
vs Melbourne +17 · R8 SCG
W
vs Western Bulldogs +66 · R7 Marvel
W
vs GWS +41 · R6 SCG
W
vs Gold Coast +32 · R5 Norwood
W
vs West Coast +128 · R4 Optus
L
vs Hawthorn -17 · R2 MCG
W
vs Brisbane Lions +44 · R1 SCG
W
vs Carlton +63 · OR SCG
W
vs Geelong +14 · SF Optus
L
vs Hawthorn -32 · F1 Optus
L
vs Carlton -37 · R24 Marvel
W
vs Adelaide +24 · R23 Optus
L
vs Melbourne -4 · R22 MCG
20 older results
W
vs Western Bulldogs +37 · R21 Optus
W
vs West Coast +70 · R20 Optus
W
vs Port Adelaide +28 · R19 Adel Oval
W
vs Sydney +38 · R18 Optus
L
vs GWS -21 · R17 Manuka Oval
W
vs Gold Coast +51 · R16 Optus
W
vs Geelong +9 · R15 Optus
W
vs North Melbourne +124 · R13 Hands Oval
W
vs Brisbane Lions +25 · R12 Gabba
W
vs St Kilda +30 · R11 Optus
W
vs Essendon +43 · R10 MCG
W
vs Hawthorn +15 · R9 Optus
W
vs Western Bulldogs +12 · R8 Marvel
W
vs Carlton +14 · R7 Optus
W
vs West Coast +56 · R6 Optus
W
vs Collingwood +6 · R5 Adel Oval
W
vs Adelaide +2 · R4 Adel Oval
W
vs Richmond +60 · R3 Optus
W
vs Melbourne +48 · R2 Optus
L
vs Geelong -10 · R1 Kardinia

Team selection

Official AFL team sheet · updated Friday Sep 18, 2026

Sydney

FB [29] Joel Hamling, [30] Tom McCartin, [24] Dane Rampe
HB [15] Sam Wicks, [32] Harry Kyle, [27] Justin McInerney
C [34] Matt Roberts, [21] Errol Gulden, [13] Jai Serong
HF [44] Jake Lloyd, [6] Logan McDonald, [2] Hayden McLean
FF [11] Tom Papley, [35] Charlie Curnow, [25] Billy Cootee
FOL [4] Brodie Grundy, [8] James Rowbottom, [16] Braeden Campbell
IC [43] Lewis Melican, [12] Angus Sheldrick, [33] Caiden Cleary, [40] Tom Hanily, [9] Jesse Dattoli
EMG [36] Joel Amartey, [45] William Green, [20] Riak Andrew
[27] Justin McInerney, [43] Lewis Melican
Callum Mills - Injured, Harry Cunningham - Injured
None listed

Fremantle

FB [6] Jordan Clark, [25] Alex Pearce, [21] Oscar McDonald
HB [23] Karl Worner, [17] Judd McVee, [5] Heath Chapman
C [44] Matthew Johnson, [8] Andrew Brayshaw, [28] Neil Erasmus
HF [32] Michael Frederick, [16] Murphy Reid, [39] Sam Switkowski
FF [24] Jye Amiss, [35] Josh Treacy, [20] Patrick Voss
FOL [9] Luke Jackson, [3] Caleb Serong, [10] Shai Bolton
IC [43] Isaiah Dudley, [18] Mason Cox, [26] Hayden Young, [34] Corey Wagner, [13] Luke Ryan
EMG [36] Brennan Cox, [45] Christopher Scerri, [2] Jaeger O'Meara
None listed
None listed
[3] Caleb Serong - 150th game